Erica was one of the most prolific softball pitchers in New Jersey during her time at Immaculata. A 4-year Varsity letter recipient, Erica was a 3-time first-team All-State pitcher from 1998-2000. In 1998, 1999, and 2000 she was named Somerset County player of the year. At Immaculata, she won the Somerset County championship in 1999 and 2000 and boasted a 0.026 ERA and a .495 batting average. She was recruited and pitched at Fairfield University in Fairfield, CT, where she had an ERA of .85 before a career-ending back injury.

Since college, Erica has coached a number of high school teams in various sports. She coached Immaculata in softball to win the Somerset County Championship in 2007, the first time the school had won since her senior year in 2000. She has conducted camps and clinics for a number of teams in Connecticut and New Jersey. Most recently she gave private pitching and hitting lessons at Ablaze Softball and East Coast Conditioning in New Jersey.