Casey Cahill was a standout baseball player while he was a student at Immaculata High School. During this time, his performances were just phenomenal. Casey was a career leader with 29 wins and 279 strikeouts. He was chosen 3 times for each of All County, All Area and All State. Casey was a two-time selection as Somerset County Player of the Year in 1999 and 2000 and was selected for the All-American High School Baseball Team in 2000. After Casey graduated from high school, he was drafted by the Baltimore Orioles in the 10th round and played in the Orioles system through 2006. Presently Casey is playing for the Somerset Patriots of the Atlantic League and has been chosen for the Atlantic League All-American High School Baseball Team in recent years.